⚖️ Manifest V3 Side-by-Side Security Comparison
Ecosia vs Gemini Watermark Cleaner
Side-by-side Manifest V3 security audit comparing Ecosia (9.4/10) and Gemini Watermark Cleaner (10/10): permissions, ratings, pros, cons, and safe ZIP downloads.
Ecosia
🛡️ 9.4/10
★ 4.4
v7.8.0
24.92KiB
The search engine that plants trees with your ad revenue
Gemini Watermark Cleaner
🛡️ 10/10
★ 3.9
v1.0.8
56.05KiB
One-click watermark removal for Google Gemini images with minimal permissions.
📊 Key Metrics Comparison
| Metric | Ecosia | Gemini Watermark Cleaner | Advantage |
|---|---|---|---|
| CRX8 Safety Score | 9.4 / 10 | 10 / 10 | Gemini Watermark Cleaner |
| Declared Permissions | 2 (0 high-risk) | 1 (0 high-risk) | Gemini Watermark Cleaner |
| Store Rating | ★ 4.4 (2449) | ★ 3.9 (8) | Ecosia |
| Active Users | 1,000,000 | 1,000 | — |
| Package Size | 24.92KiB | 56.05KiB | — |
🛡️ Manifest Permissions Diff
Comparing exact API permissions declared in each extension manifest.
| Permission | Ecosia | Gemini Watermark Cleaner |
|---|---|---|
| storage | ✓ Requested | — |
| activeTab | ✓ Requested | — |
| https://gemini.google.com/* | — | ✓ Requested |
Ecosia
👍 Pros
- +Plants 1 tree for approximately every 45 searches (verified)
- +Clean interface with search quality rivaling major engines
- +Legally binding corporate structure ensures permanent non-profit status
👎 Cons & Caveats
- −Chinese language results less localized than Baidu/Sogou
- −Smaller index than Google for niche technical queries
Gemini Watermark Cleaner
👍 Pros
- +Perfect 10/10 security score: No storage, tabs, or cookies permissions
- +No setup required - works immediately after installation
- +Seamlessly adapts to Gemini's latest UI updates
👎 Cons & Caveats
- −Exclusive to Google Gemini/AI Studio (doesn't support other AI platforms)
- −Watermark removal only works on current Gemini session images